47 pages • 1 hour read
William McDonough, Michael BraungartA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Key Figures
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
William (Bill) McDonough is co-author of Cradle to Cradle and an American architect. His worldview and design principles were shaped by experiences outside of the United States: “I was influenced strongly by experiences I’d had abroad—first in Japan, where I spent my early childhood. I recall a sense of land and resources being scarce but also the beauty of traditional Japanese homes, with their paper walls and dripping gardens, their warm futons and steaming baths” (7). One of the main tenets of McDonough’s beliefs about architecture is that it should be simple, elegant, and in line with the “natural flows” of the surrounding environment.
In 1981, he founded his own design firm based in New York, and in 1984, the Environmental Defense Fund commissioned his company to help design their “so-called green” offices. In doing so, he discovered how little research there was on environmentally-sound designs. He also discovered how the design community frowned upon environmentally-oriented designers, as “[m]any […] applied environmental ‘solutions’ in isolation, tacking new technology onto the same old model […] The resulting buildings were often ugly and obtrusive, and they were often not very effective” (9). This experience served as one of many impetuses for the McDonough to develop his and Braungart’s eco-effective model.
Michael Braungart is a co-author of the book and a German chemist. He has been interested in environmentalism and industrialism for over three decades. Although he comes from a family “of literature and philosophy scholars,” Braungart went against the grain “and turned to chemistry” (10). While studying at university, he learned about environmental chemistry. He studied with Professor Friedhelm Korte, a widely instrumental scholar in the field of ecological chemistry.
After graduating from university, Braungart became even more interested in environmental issues: “In 1978 I became one of the founding members of the Green Action Future Party. This became Germany’s Green Party, and its primary goal was taking care of the environment” (10). A pivotal moment in his career came after a massive oil spill in the late 1980s: “I coordinated a protest in which my colleagues and I chained ourselves to Ciba-Geigy smokestacks in Basel” (11). The experience of helping to alleviate the impact of those massive chemical spills in the Rhine gave an urgency to his interest in environmental issues. He is now the director of the Environmental Protection Encouragement Agency (EPEA), an environmental chemistry research agency that works with many large corporations to develop environmentally safe chemicals.
From Henry Ford in the early 1900s to his great-grandson William Clay Ford in the 1990s, many industrialists are profiled throughout the book. As a group, industrialists’ main goals involve increasing efficiency and increasing profit. Industrialists throughout history have been opposed to environmentalist intervention. The two groups are thought of as inherently opposed to one another:
On the other hand, industrialists often view environmentalism as an obstacle to production and growth. For the environment to be healthy, the conventional attitude goes, industries must be regulated and restrained. For industries to fatten, nature cannot take precedence. It appears that these two systems cannot thrive in the same world (6).
The authors take on the idea that industry is intrinsically opposed to the environment and show that this is not the case. They portray the industrialists as not an entirely bad group, despite the devastating problems their decisions have affected upon the environment:
But the general spirit of the early industrialists—and of many others at the time—was one of great optimism and faith in the progress of humankind. As industrialization boomed, other institutions emerged that assisted its rise: commercial banks, stock exchanges, and the commercial press all opened further employment opportunities for the new middle class and tightened the social network around economic growth (21).
The authors are sympathetic to the industrialists in many ways and, throughout the book, the group is portrayed as having made decisions based on the information that was available at the time: “Many industrialists, designers, and engineers did not see their designs as part of a larger system, outside of an economic one” (24).
Cradle to Cradle also profiles many environmentalists, or people who prioritize protecting the environment. Taken collectively, the authors see environmentalists as pitted against the industrialists in the popular imagination: “Environmentalists often characterize business as bad and industry itself (and the growth it demands) as inevitably destructive” (6). Since the initial stages of the Industrial Revolution in the early 20th century, there have been supporters of the environment, there to advocate in the environment’s best interest. The authors see the 1960s as a particularly pivotal time for: “Environmentalists were no longer interested simply in preservation but in monitoring and reducing toxins. Declining wilderness and diminishing resources merged with pollution and toxic waste as the major realms of concern” (48).
Current environmentalists seek to limit the growth of human beings, seeing overpopulation as one of their chief concerns: “The association of growth with negative consequences has become a major theme of environmentalists in the modern age” (49). The authors, however, take issue with this. They see a world of abundance, not limits. Their contribution to environmentalist vision is to allow them to see greater, broader possibilities.