logo

49 pages 1 hour read

Lisa See

Lady Tan's Circle of Women

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Power of Women’s Alliances

A prevailing theme of the novel is the strength that female relationships provide as support, nurturance, rescue, and mainstay throughout a woman’s life. While a woman of Yunxian’s status is raised, as the injunctions of the opening chapter suggest, to please and serve a husband, Yunxian learns early on that the “circle of good” (66) provided by the women in her life will nourish and sustain her far more than her marriage will.

Yunxian receives her first hint at the importance of creating female alliances when she travels to her grandparents’ home. Miss Zhao, her father’s concubine and Yunxian’s chaperone, knows she cannot replace Yunxian’s mother but reminds the girl that she will be in a new place and will need to cultivate friends. The power and strength of this friendship endure for many years, as Miss Zhao steps in later to accompany Yunxian to Beijing and also helps her tend the smallpox outbreak in the Garden of Fragrant Delights. As a concubine who could be sold at any moment, Miss Zhao’s position in the Tan household is only assured by her status as the mother of Master Tan’s surviving son, but her motives are based on genuine friendship, as she risks her own welfare to help Yunxian in her times of need.

Another of the pillars in Yunxian’s circle of women is Grandmother Ru. Her grandmother embraces Yunxian from the beginning and entrusts her with the training that has been passed down through her family of practitioners of traditional medicine. Grandmother cultivates Yunxian’s gifts from girlhood and provides her with the means to be of material help and support to other women. Grandmother appears each time Yunxian is ill, even visiting after death to prove that her influence endures. As her medical mentor and mother figure, Grandmother provides the nurturance, guidance, and instruction that Yunxian needs.

The strongest testimony to the power of female friendship is the way that Meiling and Yunxian save each other’s lives. While their early friendship offers ease for Yunxian’s loneliness and provides a peek at the outer world, Meiling’s friendship becomes Yunxian’s strongest support. Meiling saves Yunxian’s life when she corrects the breech position of her first baby, then tends Yunxian through her postpartum illnesses. She encourages, even demands, that Yunxian pursue her passion and put her medical knowledge to use, and she helps Yunxian develop the book that will become her lasting legacy.

In turn, Yunxian learns the value of loyalty and devotion when she visits Meiling even though her mother-in-law disapproves—Meiling’s friendship is worth the risk. Yunxian saves Meiling’s life after her miscarriage and beating by the emperor’s guards, and she administers the remedies that help Meiling, at long last, bear a healthy son. While Yunxian maintains a pleasant relationship with her husband, she knows she is not of primary importance to him, but she knows she is of the same vital worth to Meiling as Meiling is to her. Their friendship thus stands for the ideal female companionship. While women have supported her throughout every stage of her life, Yunxian reflects at the end of the novel that Meiling has been her truest companion and truest friend, a relationship that continues to bring her joy.

The Conflict Between Tradition and Ambition

While Yunxian is eager to please her family members and fulfill the duties expected of her, throughout the novel she experiences an internal conflict over her loyalty to the cultural values and traditions that enclose her and her wish to see more of the world. Both of these interests cause her satisfaction and a degree of pain, but her character arc throughout the novel follows her quest to balance these competing interests and maintain harmony in her life.

Yunxian’s chief conflict stems from her desire to use the medical knowledge that her grandmother has passed on to her. When it comes to choosing obedience, complying with Lady Kuo’s injunction to leave the medical advice to Doctor Wong, and helping where help is needed, Yunxian chooses to act. In upholding the greater good by ministering to the health of those around her, Yunxian is still adhering to the Confucian principles that she has been taught undergird an ethical and properly-ordered society. She is also able to act on her compassion and the need for justice that strongly rule her character. In this light, her two desires are not in opposition but in harmony.

Yunxian also grows in confidence and ambition as the novel progresses. When Meiling is sentenced to death, she intercedes with the emperor and empress to save her friend’s life. When she uncovers incriminating information about Doctor Wong, she writes to her father and pushes for a proper inquest into Spinster Aunt’s murder, ensuring that justice is at last done. Above all, her devotion to her medical practice ultimately wins out against her mother-in-law’s objections, enabling her to practice medicine more openly. It is the book of cases she publishes that secures her lasting fame in Chinese medical history, validating the intellectual and practical ambitions she remains loyal to throughout her life.

In the end, as symbolized when she permits her family to picnic at the Dragon Boat Festival, Yunxian is able to harmonize her wish to fulfill her expected duties as a woman but also use her gifts as a doctor. Her grandmother provides the model for being a proper Confucian woman and a physician. While Yunxian still subscribes to tradition—as shown when she personally oversees the binding of the feet of the family’s girls—her larger goal is to protect women’s health, and this she accomplishes by sharing her cases with the world in the form of her book. Yunxian proves that, like the balance of yin and yang, outside concerns need not take away from domestic duties, but that it is important to find the courage to fulfill both.

The Subordinate Status of Women

Throughout the novel, while remaining respectful of the traditions and beliefs of Ming dynasty China, See demonstrates the ill-effects that these beliefs can have on women’s lives. The novel explores the subordinate status experienced by women of all social classes, suggesting that allowing women to exercise interests and professions outside of their relationship to men leads to healthier outcomes for all.

Yunxian learns early from her mother’s instruction that being considered a respectable woman means obedience, submission, and pain. Women shape themselves for the pleasure of men by binding their feet, silencing their voices, and burying any resentment they feel at ill-treatment. As Yunxian discovers, the well-to-do women in imperial China are the most secluded. Aside from visits to her grandparents, as a married woman Yunxian is expected never to leave the Garden of Fragrant Delights. Her home is a beautiful and elaborate cage designed to keep her from being soiled by contact with the world of commerce, poverty, and public affairs. Yunxian is prone to melancholy, especially in her younger years, exhibiting the influence of her confinement.

The concubines, while more educated and allowed more opportunities to see the world, also have a subordinate status. When young, Yunxian envies that Miss Zhao and the other concubines she meets have seen more of the world. They know of current events, such as the need to rebuild the Great Wall to guard against invasion or the laws being passed by the emperor. However, a concubine can be sold at any time if she no longer pleases her “master.” An example of the precariousness of their lives is when one of Grandfather’s concubines is sold off after breaking her leg: Concubines, for all their accomplishments, are treated no differently than any other possession.  

Women who work in other trades, as Yunxian finds, are less restricted in their movements but not always better off. The bricklayer Yunxian treats experiences exhaustion because she is obliged to complete the daily work while her husband enjoys leisure activities. Yunxian also treats a young wife who has become physically ill with sorrow due to her husband’s neglect after childbirth, perhaps an example of postpartum depression. This proves that the patriarchal arrangement that privileges men’s freedom over women’s well-being and agency can cause lasting damage at all social levels.

Grandfather Ru’s example as both a strong matriarch and practicing physician provides an alternative for Yunxian. In gaining knowledge and practicing valuable skills, Yunxian becomes more than a traditional wife and mother, giving her an outlet for her talents. Most significantly of all, in valuing the lives and health of women—and treating a bricklayer with the same care as she treats the empress—Yunxian works against this cultural belief to suggest that every woman’s life matters, and that women deserve to enjoy health and happiness as much as men do.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text