logo

54 pages 1 hour read

M. T. Anderson

Landscape with Invisible Hand

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2017

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Ups and Downs of Young Love

Teen relationships in the novel represent the steep learning curve and instability of young love. Adam is attracted to Chloe from the beginning and fears embarrassing himself in front of her. Upon meeting Chloe, Adam finds that she’s empathetic, as the text depicts through her attentiveness during dinner. While Adam is painting a portrait of her, the two have the opportunity to develop romantic intimacy. The romance in their relationship results from the intimate circumstances of their families living together and of Adam using Chloe as a model, rather than from any real compatibility. Like many young relationships, Adam and Chloe’s bond is both intense and naive. They’re absorbed in the excitement and thus able to better endure their extreme poverty and to ignore the things they dislike about each other: “At that point, it didn’t even matter that Chloe and I were often standing knee-deep in piles of garbage and filth in the shadow of rich-people floating houses. We were in love” (31). Their relationship deteriorates for three main reasons: First, their families live together, so they witness each other at their worst; second, the reality show further strains their relationship; and third, their personalities are seemingly incompatible in that Adam is an introvert and prefers solitude and introspection, while Chloe is an extrovert who craves popularity and social interaction.

Unlike typical teens, Adam and Chloe are unable to end their relationship because of their participation in the vuvv reality show, which is the primary income for both their families. Chloe, who has found a new relationship, finally breaks completely with Adam after Adam has uncontrolled diarrhea in an alley. Her disgust for her ex-boyfriend and her excitement for her new relationship with Buddy overcome her desire for financially assisting her family. Again, unlike typical teen relationships, Chloe and Adam live together and become hostile toward one another. While Chloe remains hostile even after entering into a new contract to film her relationship with Buddy, Adam’s perspective shifts to indifference by the end of the novel, after he, too, finds a new romantic interest in Lucy. His relationship with Chloe taught him valuable lessons, including that young love, while intense, isn’t generally long-lasting. Having learned the hard way, Adam advises Nattie not to make the same mistake after she expresses her desire to film dates with her new boyfriend, Michael, for the vuvv reality show. The young love theme helps develop the overarching anti-capitalist message of the novel because the author uses the commodification of relationships to demonstrate corrupt capitalism. Additionally, the theme enhances the relatability of the text because many people have experienced such up-and-down relationships in their own lives.

Expressing Truth Through Art

One of Adam’s primary conflicts involves expressing truth versus expressing fantasy in his art. Many of his early works of art depict idyllic conditions, but Adam progresses into painting landscapes that show the world as it is in the present day. In addition, after his father abandons the family, he adjusts from using digital programs to using actual paints and canvasses. By using physical rather than digital materials, Adam’s art takes up space and draws attention. The combination of the physical paintings and the truthful depictions reflects the importance of representing the truth in art. Shirley, the official from the vuvv-sponsored art contest, is interested in taking Adam’s fantasy paintings. The contest’s sponsors argue that other species won’t want to see the reality of life on Earth:

No one on another world is going to want a picture of a vuvv discharge facility hanging on the wall of their gorging chamber or their dormancy pit. They want to see beautiful, strange vistas of an exotic world, where they might vacation for a period of days to weeks, depending on their work availability and gravitational jump-space time displacement (85).

While Adam initially intends to concede to Shirley’s argument, he changes his mind when he witnesses Mrs. Gregson’s demeaning attitude toward Mr. Reilly. Adam submits his realistic landscapes in the hopes that, by expressing the truth through his art, he can fight against the oppressive conditions.

Adam and Buddy become foils through their artistic endeavors. Whereas Adam paints the truth, Buddy panders to the vuvv by creating absurd chainsaw sculptures. Buddy understands that the vuvv don’t have enough respect for humans to try to understand human culture. Instead, the vuvv commodify human culture. The theme of expressing truth via art becomes ironic when Buddy wins the contest because of Adam’s realistic painting. Earlier in the novel, the author presents the idea of expressing truth through art as morally superior, and the text intentionally points toward a positive outcome for Adam. Adam’s loss is likely not solely a result of Buddy’s pandering sculptures. The realistic paintings depict the presence of the vuvv in a negative light. Adam seals his fate to lose the competition by criticizing the species who organized the contest in the first place. The interpretation of Adam’s loss extends beyond the context of the novel, and it becomes an allusion for the devaluation of truth in society. The author criticizes society for valuing entertainment and false beauty over truth. In addition, he highlights the recent decline in support for the liberal arts and humanities disciplines in favor of technological advancement. By satirizing these concepts, the author emphasizes that such disciplines are culturally valuable.

Capitalism and the Wealth Gap

The societal effects of capitalism and the wealth gap it increasingly creates is the primary theme throughout Landscape with Invisible Hand. The setting, characters, and secondary themes contribute to developing this overarching theme, which is central to the text’s anti-capitalist message. The story is set in a futuristic capitalist world that the technologically advanced vuvv have taken over. The vuvv strongly value consumerism, as Shirley describes: “We’ve lost the path, you know, with all this commercialization” (83). Shirley’s assertion that humans contrast the vuvv in that they’re spiritual is ironic because human culture generally values consumerism over spirituality. The vuvv invasion results in an extreme wealth gap, which creates the poverty conditions on the planet’s surface. Although the author uses science fiction pretenses to depict the wealth gap, he’s satirizing the increasing gap between the upper and lower class in the real world.

The plot events and characters develop this theme by representing certain impacts and perspectives. Adam’s family falls into poverty when Mr. and Mrs. Costello lose their jobs. Mr. Costello, who is self-serving, flees to avoid the burden of caring for his family. His character represents the concept that capitalism leads to extreme individualism. Mrs. Costello, who fights to remain optimistic while persistently job searching, represents the anti-capitalist argument that one can’t overcome poverty simply by working hard. Similarly, Hunter Marsh, who idolizes and emulates the vuvv, hopes to escape poverty by becoming vuvv-like; however, his imitative behaviors improve neither his social nor financial status. Mr. Reilly represents the middle class. He has a reliable job and makes enough money to get by but doesn’t benefit from the capitalist society. He serves those who live in poverty by volunteering to teach art, while being degraded by the wealthy upper class. Although he makes enough to support himself, he can’t afford luxuries or conveniences, which is why he eagerly eats the steak the Gregsons give him. Adam, Chloe, and Nattie each experience shortened childhoods because they must help financially support their families. The loss is especially tragic in Nattie, who at 12 years old, sells her toys and offers to risk future consequences by selling footage of herself and her new boyfriend dating.

The other two themes, Expressing Truth Through Art and the Ups and Downs of Young Love, help develop the overarching theme of capitalism and the widening wealth gap. Adam’s truthful art acts as a physical representation of the negative consequences of unchecked capitalism and consumerism. Relationships, too, are impacted negatively by consumerism and wealth gaps. Chloe and Adam feel obligated to keep presenting themselves as a loving couple because if they stop, both their families will lose their primary income. The profits inspire Chloe to partake in the show again with Buddy, although she already experienced one failed attempt, which ended in a lawsuit. Nattie, too, offers to sell her relationship to the vuvv despite the risk. The family members do what they must to survive extreme poverty. By making the theme of capitalism and the wealth gap the novel’s central feature, the author sends a warning about the current economic, political, and social trends in the US and grounds the text in satirical fiction.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text