logo

49 pages 1 hour read

Molly Bang

Picture This: How Pictures Work

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 1991

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Preface-Chapter 1Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Preface Summary

In the preface to her book Picture This, Molly Bang shares the story of her journey to uncover the principles that govern the emotional impact of pictures. The narrative begins with Bang, a successful children’s book writer and illustrator, sketching objects around her house. During this time, her old friend, Leon, paid her a visit and suggested that instead of drawing isolated objects, she should attempt to create whole pictures, capturing entire scenes. As Bang tried to follow Leon’s advice, she became increasingly lost and confused. Leon, observing her struggle, bluntly pointed out that Bang didn’t really understand how pictures work, specifically in terms of picture structure.

Recognizing her lack of understanding, Bang resolved to educate herself. She enrolled in a painting course and delved into books on art and the psychology of art. She also spent time in museums and galleries, studying paintings and trying to discern how they made her feel and what elements contributed to those emotions. In addition to her studies, Bang decided to teach picture-making to her daughter’s third-grade class, believing that the process of teaching would further her own learning. During this experience, Bang and the children used simple shapes cut from construction paper in four colors (red, black, pale purple, and white) to create illustrations for the story of “Little Red Riding Hood.” As they worked together, adjusting the pictures to evoke different emotions such as comfort or fear, both Bang and the children realized that they possessed an innate understanding of how certain elements in pictures affect one’s feelings.

Energized by this realization, Bang continued her exploration of picture composition using construction paper and scissors. She arranged simple shapes and colors, observing and contemplating how these arrangements influenced her emotions. She then shared her findings with eighth and ninth graders and later with adults. The pictures created by her students and adult learners reinforced Bang’s belief that anyone, regardless of age or background, can utilize a few clear principles to create visually powerful and emotionally charged compositions.

Eager to validate her discoveries, Bang wrote up her findings and sent them to Rudolf Arnheim, a respected psychologist known for his work in the psychology of art. Arnheim responded positively to Bang’s manuscript and provided detailed feedback, commenting on nearly every page. When Bang asked Arnheim to summarize her work in his own words, he explained that her book uses geometrical shapes not merely as abstract forms or pure perceptual elements but as dynamic expressions of natural and human behavior. He noted that her approach strips away the prettiness often associated with fairy tales, reducing the story to its basic sensations and reinforcing the fundamental human actions derived from direct visual sensations. Arnheim compared the strength of Bang’s shapes to that of puppets or primitive wood carvings, emphasizing their ability to exploit the elementary powers of abstraction.

Arnheim’s response confirmed Bang’s belief that she had tapped into a fundamental connection between emotions and how people perceive pictures. The preface concludes with Bang stating that her book is dedicated to exploring a single, crucial question: how the structure of a picture influences one’s emotional response. This question—which arose from her observations of the principles taking shape in her work with the children and her own experiments—has been the driving force behind her continued contemplation of the relationship between visual composition and emotional impact.

Chapter 1 Summary: “Building the Emotional Content of Pictures”

In Chapter 1, Bang delves into the intricate relationship between the various elements of a picture and the emotional responses they elicit from the viewer. She begins by emphasizing the importance of context in shaping people’s perceptions and reactions to shapes. Bang argues that a picture’s emotional impact is not solely determined by its individual components but rather by the interplay between these elements and the context in which they are presented.

To illustrate her points, Bang uses the classic fairy tale of Little Red Riding Hood as a case study. She starts by representing the protagonist as a simple geometric shape: a little red triangle. Bang analyzes the emotional associations evoked by this shape and color combination. She notes that the triangle’s flat, wide base suggests stability, while its equal sides convey a sense of balance. The pointed corners, however, make the shape less huggable and more alert. Bang then explores the psychological implications of the color red, associating it with warmth, boldness, vitality, and a hint of danger. She traces these emotional responses back to the human experience of blood and fire, two fundamental red elements that have been part of human perception since the dawn of time.

Next, Bang experiments with depicting Little Red Riding Hood’s mother. Initially, she represents the mother as a larger red triangle, but she quickly realizes that this choice overshadows the protagonist and disrupts the visual hierarchy of the picture. By rounding the corners of the mother’s shape and changing her color to pale purple, Bang successfully makes the mother appear more huggable and less overwhelming. This modification also maintains a color connection between the mother and daughter, as purple contains red, subtly suggesting their familial bond. Bang’s iterative process highlights the importance of considering the relative size, shape, and color of elements within a picture to create the desired emotional effect.

As the picture develops, Bang introduces a small black semicircle to represent a basket. Her choice of black for this element is deliberate, as she recognizes its attention-grabbing properties and potential to evoke a wide range of emotions. To depict the woods, Bang employs long, rectangular black shapes of varying lengths and widths, reminiscent of tall, branchless tree trunks. By placing the small red triangle (Little Red Riding Hood) within this context, Bang experiences a strong identification with the character, underscoring the power of visual storytelling to create empathy between the viewer and the subject.

To heighten the sense of fear and vulnerability, Bang experiments with the size and placement of Little Red Riding Hood within the picture. She discovers that making the character smaller intensifies the viewer’s emotional response, as it taps into the primal fear of being small and helpless in the face of danger. Bang also explores the impact of the character’s position on the page, noting that increasing the distance between Little Red Riding Hood and the viewer reduces the emotional connection. This observation highlights the importance of considering the spatial relationships within a picture to control the viewer’s engagement with the story.

Bang further enhances the sense of danger and unease by tilting some of the tree trunks in the woods. This simple adjustment creates movement, tension, and a potential threat, as the leaning trees appear to be on the verge of falling. Bang notes that diagonal lines are a powerful tool for conveying motion, tying elements together, and influencing the protagonist’s progress through the pictorial space. By strategically placing the tilted trees, Bang can block or lead Little Red Riding Hood’s path, guiding the viewer’s eye and shaping their emotional journey through the picture.

When composing the wolf, Bang employs three large, black, pointed triangles that lean aggressively toward Little Red Riding Hood. The size, color, and shape of these triangles work together to create an overwhelming sense of danger and menace. Bang experiments with altering various aspects of the wolf, such as its size, color, and shape, to study how these changes affect the viewer’s perception. She emphasizes the importance of striking a delicate balance between ambiguity and clarity in visual storytelling. While a certain level of ambiguity can engage the audience and stimulate their imagination, too much can lead to confusion and alienation. Bang cautions against pushing ambiguity too far, as it may cause viewers to feel rejected and frustrated when they cannot grasp the emotional content of the picture.

In her exploration of the wolf’s features, Bang pays special attention to its teeth, depicting them as small, sharp, black triangles. She explains that exaggerating the scary aspects of a threat can be more effective in eliciting an emotional response than striving for photorealistic accuracy. This approach taps into the viewer’s subjective experience of fear, where the perception of danger often overshadows objective reality. By focusing on the most frightening features and amplifying them, Bang creates a more visceral and emotionally engaging picture.

When adding the wolf’s eye, Bang initially uses purple but later changes it to red. This choice creates a strong visual and emotional connection between Little Red Riding Hood and the wolf’s gaze. By using the same color for both elements, Bang implies a direct and intense relationship between the protagonist and the antagonist. She also discusses the psychological impact of the color red, noting that psychologists have found that people tend to be more aggressive in bright-red and hot-pink rooms and consume more food in rooms with red walls. Bang suggests that this may be due to the deep-rooted association of red with blood and fire.

To further intensify the danger and draw the viewer into the scene, Bang adds a large red tongue to the wolf’s mouth. This addition creates a strong visual pull, making it appear as though Little Red Riding Hood is being drawn inexorably toward the wolf’s gaping maw. Bang likens this effect to a gravitational force, with the large mass of red color attracting the viewer’s attention and heightening the sense of impending doom.

Finally, Bang manipulates the picture’s background color, changing it to purple. This choice implies nighttime or deep shadow, creating a dark and foreboding atmosphere. Bang explains that darkness tends to evoke a greater sense of fear than light, as it taps into the primal human fear of the unknown and unseen. By placing the wolf’s white teeth against this dark background, Bang creates a stark contrast that further emphasizes their sharpness and menace. She notes that the effectiveness of the white is enhanced by its judicious use, demonstrating the power of strategic color placement in shaping the picture’s emotional impact.

In concluding the chapter, Bang emphasizes that the power of pictures lies in their ability to tap into primal human experiences and emotions, making them an extension of the real world. By learning and applying these principles, artists and visual storytellers can understand “how pictures work” (50).

Preface-Chapter 1 Analysis

Bang explores The Emotional Power of Visual Elements through her experiments with the story of Little Red Riding Hood. As with her children’s books, Bang uses visual language and illustrations to convey meaning, though in this case, she uses them as educational examples. In a book about visual vocabulary and interpretation, showing illustrations provides evidence for Bang’s assertions. She carefully manipulates shapes, colors, sizes, and positions to evoke a range of emotions, from the comfort and stability of the red triangle representing Little Red Riding Hood to the fear and unease created by the wolf’s large, black, pointed triangles. Bang explores her own emotions, such as when she lists out her responses to Little Red Riding Hood: “These, then, are the feelings I have for this medium-sized red triangle: stability, balance, a prickliness or alertness, plus warmth, strength, vitality, boldness, and perhaps some sense of danger” (4). Bang shows that by viewing even the simplest of shapes in their context, people can feel strong and nuanced emotional responses. By adjusting factors such as the size and placement of the protagonist, the tilt of the tree trunks, and the color and shape of the wolf, Bang controls the viewer’s emotional journey, creating a powerful and engaging visual narrative. She also demonstrates how the interplay between these visual elements and their context can shape the viewer’s perceptions and emotional responses, such as how changing the mother’s shape and color from a large red triangle to a rounded, pale purple shape makes her appear more huggable—and therefore maternal—and less overwhelming.

Throughout the Preface and Chapter 1, Bang highlights The Primal Nature of Color and Shape and how they tap into deep-rooted human experiences and emotions. In the Preface, she describes her process of studying paintings and trying to discern how they made her feel. In doing so, she recognized the innate understanding that people have of visual language. In Chapter 1, Bang delves deeper into the primal associations of colors and shapes. For example, in discussing the color red, she says, “Part of the reason may be that we associate red with blood and fire, so this is a bloody, fiery eye rather than an eye associated with flowers or with the evening sky” (39). She suggests, “Maybe it’s because we've seen drunken, bloodshot eyes, or eyes reflected in a campfire, and those were red. In some fairy tales, the eyes of witches are described as being red” (39). She links these primal associations with the psychological implications of red, such as its associations with warmth, boldness, vitality, and danger, which can evoke powerful emotional responses in the viewer: “What is red? Blood and fire. Ah. The feelings evoked in me by red all seem to be associated with these two things that have been red and only red ever since humans have been around to see them” (4). Bang implies that humans react to color according to their evolutionary instincts, suggesting that certain emotional aspects of visual perception are universal and innate.

Bang emphasizes the theme of The Picture as an Extension of Real Life in these opening chapters. While viewing a picture, viewers connect with it and experience emotions in a way that mirrors their interactions with the world around them. In the Preface, she describes how her friend Leon encouraged her to create whole pictures, capturing entire scenes, rather than sketching isolated objects. This advice led Bang to recognize the importance of context in shaping people’s perceptions and reactions to shapes; the emotional impact of a picture is determined by the interplay between its components and the context in which they are presented. In Chapter 1, Bang further explores this concept through her experiments with Little Red Riding Hood. This figure remains the same red triangle throughout, but the different contexts in which Bang places her evoke different feelings. During these experiments, Bang says, “I finally realized that when Little Red Riding Hood is more distant from me, I don't identify with her or sympathize with her so much as before” (23). However, she demonstrates how carefully composing a picture, such as placing the small red triangle within the context of the tall, black tree trunks, can create identification between the viewer and the subject, fostering empathy and emotional engagement. By manipulating elements such as Little Red Riding Hood’s size and position, Bang shows how visual storytelling can tap into human experiences, such as the fear of being small and helpless in the face of danger. She explicitly connects these emotional experiences to the fact that pictures appear to be an extension of life: “How do pictures make us feel in specific ways? We see pictures as extensions of the real world” (49-50). Through her analysis of the principles of picture composition, Bang illustrates how artists and visual storytellers can create works that resonate deeply with their audiences, evoking the charge of real-life experiences through visual art.

In the Preface, Bang positions visual principles as innate and instinctual, emotionally felt but not always consciously recognized. She builds ethos by sharing her own journey as a successful illustrator who, despite her achievements, struggled to understand the fundamental principles of picture composition. As she studied art and examined how pictures made her feel, Bang began to recognize that visual principles feel innate, even if they are difficult to articulate. Her experiences teaching picture-making to her daughter’s third-grade class further reinforced this idea, as both Bang and the children realized that they possessed an instinctual grasp of how simple shapes and colors could evoke different emotions. Bang’s personal journey and the insights gained from working with children and adults led her to believe that humans have an inherent understanding of how pictures work. Her book represents her effort to bridge the gap between instinctual understanding and conscious awareness, making these principles accessible to others and demonstrating that anyone can learn to create emotionally powerful pictures.

Throughout Chapter 1, Bang employs an iterative process, guiding the reader through her thought process as she composes the image of Little Red Riding Hood. She starts by representing the protagonist as a simple red triangle and analyzes the emotional associations evoked by this shape and color combination. As she develops the picture, Bang introduces new elements, such as the mother, the basket, the woods, and the wolf, and she experiments with their size, color, and placement to create the desired emotional effect. For example, when depicting the mother, Bang initially uses a larger red triangle but quickly realizes that this choice overshadows the protagonist and disrupts the visual hierarchy of the picture. By rounding the corners of the mother’s shape and changing her color to pale purple, Bang maintains a visual tie between the two characters while letting Little Red Riding Hood shine as the protagonist. This iterative process is an effective teaching tool, allowing readers to witness the evolution of the picture and understand the reasoning behind each compositional choice.

Bang’s approach emphasizes the importance of play, experimentation, and exploration in creating emotionally powerful pictures. She encourages readers to engage with their own emotional responses and trust their instincts when making compositional decisions, such as when she adjusts the size and placement of Little Red Riding Hood to intensify feelings of fear and vulnerability. By checking in with one’s feelings and making adjustments based on the desired emotional impact, Bang suggests that artists and visual storytellers can create dynamic and interactive narratives that resonate with their audiences.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text