54 pages • 1 hour read
Ashley PostonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
As they walk toward Washington Square Park, Iwan tries to make amends for how he acted after their meeting, and the two start to again become friendly toward one another. Clementine continues to notice all the ways he has both changed and stayed the same, and wonders if he would consider her a friend in this timeline.
Clementine and Iwan arrive at a bright yellow food truck called “Yo Mama’s Fajitas” that Iwan’s friends Miguel and Isa own. Iwan introduces Clementine as Lemon, saying they are old acquaintances. Clementine realizes that these are the same fajitas that he made her the first night they met, which he had told her was the recipe of a friend whom he was going to convince to get a food truck. Clementine sees more of the old Iwan in him as he jokes around with his friends. They talk about the past as they eat their fajitas, and Iwan mentions how his grandfather passed shortly after he started at the Olive Branch. Iwan seems to Clementine somewhat regretful about the past seven years, though he only says he regrets not being there for her. Clementine asks why he never tried to find her, and she is confused when he tells her she wouldn’t have believed him if he tried.
Iwan reveals that he knows about the time slip, and how, if he had found her seven years earlier, she would not have known him. Clementine knows this must mean that she sees him in the past at least once more, but when she asks about it, he refuses to tell her what happened then. Miguel and Isa join them after they close the food truck, and they joke about their days in culinary school. Isa asks Clementine why she loves publishing, but she doesn't feel the passion she used to feel for it. When Iwan goes to throw out their trash, Isa and Miguel lament about how they think Iwan is going to burn out. While Clementine tries to add that he is doing it to make his grandfather proud, Miguel wonders when he will do something for himself. The old friends continue to talk about the past, and Miguel and Isa remember how Iwan was obsessed with a girl named Clementine.
Iwan walks Clementine to the subway as she continues to think about their past together, but when she tries to kiss him, he pulls away. He mentions how she is off-limits, and Clementine recognizes how she nearly jeopardized her professionalism for him. As she leaves, she thinks about how nothing can stay forever.
When she returns to her apartment, Clementine is shocked to see Iwan there, seven years in the past. Clementine knows she is breaking her aunt’s rule about falling in love in the apartment as the two have sex, and she knows the inevitable end of this relationship will shatter her.
The next morning, Iwan sees that the two pigeons that live outside the apartment have been watching them, and Clementine starts to believe her aunt’s story that they are the same two birds that had been there indefinitely. Clementine accidentally refers to Analea in the past tense and Iwan notices, leading her to want to tell him the truth about the magical apartment, but she lies instead. Iwan suggests that they go out in the city that day, causing Clementine to panic. As soon as he steps out of the apartment, Iwan vanishes, leaving Clementine alone in the present.
Clementine tries to go back to the past again but is unable to. Outside, a storm has begun, and she remembers how Analea always made a point of dancing in the rain. Earl the doorman tells Clementine she has something in her mailbox, and she finds a handwritten letter from Vera. Panicking, Clementine invites Drew and Fiona out to dinner for an emergency meeting, but the restaurant they want to go to is busy. They instead go to Yo Mama’s Fajitas. When asked about it, Clementine is forced to tell the half-truth that James Ashton had shown her the food truck the night before, and her friends are both surprised. Clementine shows them the letter from Vera, and Fiona suggests that Clementine needs to break the news of Analea’s death to Vera as she hadn’t known that the two had kept in touch.
Miguel and Isa are happy to see Clementine, but Drew and Fiona are surprised when they call her Lemon and mention Iwan, who happens to be there. Clementine runs into him and notices that, like her, he is extremely hungover from the night before, despite their respective nights being seven years apart. Clementine reminds herself that Iwan is off-limits as she guides her friends away from the food truck so they don’t see him.
Over the next few days, Clementine thinks about Vera and why Analea had stayed in the apartment even after her heartbreak, but she refuses to read Vera’s letter. At work, Rhonda talks to Clementine about her promotion, where she is reminded that both the imprint and her career are dependent upon her acquiring James Ashton’s book. She remembers how she spent the summer seven years earlier, when Analea convinced Clementine to go with her on vacation. She thinks of the woman she used to be, and how she has since tried to turn herself into someone like Rhonda instead. Drew submits the second proposal for Iwan’s book, and Lauren invites their team to the soft opening of his new restaurant. Clementine asks Drew and Fiona to go with her to return the letter to Vera.
In these chapters, Clementine finally begins to see glimpses of the old Iwan behind the facade he has built as James Ashton. When he takes Clementine to Yo Mama’s Fajitas, she is reminded of the first night they met when he made her the same fajitas and mentioned he wanted his friend to open a food truck. Throughout Chapter 27, she begins to see how Iwan is still the same around his friends, mentioning that “This was the part of him I feared had disappeared, but he’d just schooled it and kept it hidden for friends who wouldn’t give up his secret” (182). She begins to see how they both wear masks around others but can also still have parts of themselves expressed in other ways. However, when Clementine brings up the fact that she misses seeing Iwan so passionate about food, he responds, “I’m always passionate about it” (183), not being able to see the ways he has changed over seven years. The sharp time jumps Clementine is experiencing because of the apartment helps her to identify the changes in Iwan more readily than he can identify then in himself.
When Miguel and Isa mention that Iwan was once in love with a girl named Clementine, she begins to wonder if he actually is happy to see her. The Acceptance of Change and Personal Growth is revisited again as Clementine begins to open up to the idea of positive, or even neutral, change in Iwan, whereas she previously only focused on negative change. It is at this point that Clementine finally begins to realize that some things change while others stay the same, something she will have to continue to accept by the novel’s conclusion. A large part of her journey towards this acceptance lies in The Complexities of Grief as she mourns the loss of her aunt and what this means for her past, present, and future self.
More framework of the elements of magical realism are revealed in these chapters as the lines between the past and present become even more blurry. It is revealed that Iwan knows about the time slip in the apartment, yet he cannot say exactly what happened between them or how he figured it out. This leaves open to reader interpretation the question of whether or not Clementine’s future actions will affect his past. When Clementine goes to Yo Mama’s Fajitas with her friends and finds Iwan there, she is shocked to see how they have had similar nights, despite a difference in seven years. Their feelings also begin to repeat across the past and the present timelines, leaving the boundary between them thin. As a whole, this uncertainty leaves Clementine wondering what Iwan actually feels about her and if he knows himself.
Here Clementine is finally beginning to see that there is a difference between what she wants and what she thinks she wants. In Chapter 29, when Iwan refuses to kiss her, she recognizes she is not supposed to want him to, even though she does. She says, “What scared me wasn’t the fact that I hadn’t even thought twice about kissing him—it was that I hadn’t cared about my career at all. About what Rhonda would think. About throwing away seven years of overtime and sleepless weekends and papercuts” (198). Though she wants to be with Iwan, she knows it conflicts with the job she has dedicated all of her time and effort to, which she does so she doesn’t have to face the changes she is so afraid of. When she meets with Rhonda in Chapter 32, she sees the life she thinks she wants, yet she is not excited or passionate about it.
It isn’t just Clementine whose expectations for the future are blinding her to her present—she sees how Iwan does this as well. All of his friends comment that he is working himself too hard not because he loves the work but because he wants to make his grandfather proud, one of the main ideas inspiring him to cook. Miguel knows this but asks “at what point should he start wanting to do something for himself?” (193), summing up Clementine's new thoughts about herself and further showing the ways she and Iwan are alike.
By Ashley Poston